How to Get Letters of Recommendation That Really Make an Impact

teacher

Getting letters of recommendation that resonate with college admissions officers can make a strong impact on your application. These letters give insight into who you are beyond grades and test scores, highlighting your personality, strengths, and growth. Here are steps to ensure you secure impactful recommendations.

1. Choose Recommenders Who Know You Well

Select people who can speak to your unique qualities, like teachers you've worked with closely in recent years, mentors who’ve seen you grow, or activity leaders who can vouch for your character. Colleges prefer teachers from core subjects like English, math, science, or social studies, especially if you’ve excelled or shown dedication in their classes. A teacher who only knows you from a large class might provide a generic letter, while someone who knows your strengths and work ethic can offer a compelling narrative.

For instance, if you excelled in your biology class and engaged frequently in lab work, the biology teacher might highlight your curiosity and analytical skills in ways that feel authentic. Or, a debate coach can emphasize your communication skills, resilience, and ability to work under pressure if you participated in competitions.

2. Make a Strong Request Early

Asking early, ideally several months before the deadline, allows your recommenders enough time to craft a well-thought-out letter. Rushed letters are often generic and lack depth, which can be a disadvantage. When making the request, try to do it in person if possible and explain why you think their recommendation would be meaningful for your application.

An example request might sound like: “I’ve learned a lot in your class, and I feel that you have a unique understanding of my strengths. I’d be grateful if you could provide a letter of recommendation that reflects the dedication I’ve shown.” This approach shows both appreciation and purpose, helping the teacher understand that their input is valuable.

3. Provide Supporting Materials

Help your recommenders write a detailed letter by providing a “brag sheet” that summarizes your achievements, goals, and experiences relevant to their relationship with you. This isn’t about impressing them; it’s about giving them information they may have forgotten or weren’t aware of. You could include:

- A list of projects, assignments, or achievements from their class or program

- Your career or college goals and how their course has influenced these

- Any extracurricular activities you’re involved in, especially those that connect with the skills you displayed in their class

An example of what you might include is, “I led a community project where I applied the skills learned in your environmental science class to raise awareness about recycling. This experience cemented my interest in environmental studies.”

4. Be Specific About What You Need

Each letter should ideally align with the values or focus areas of the colleges you’re applying to. For instance, if you’re applying to a college with a strong engineering program, a teacher might emphasize your problem-solving abilities and interest in mathematics. If it’s a liberal arts college, they might focus on your curiosity, creativity, or interdisciplinary approach to learning. Let your recommenders know what you want colleges to understand about you.

Example: “I’m applying to liberal arts programs and would love for you to highlight how my curiosity in your class helped me pursue independent research.” This helps them frame their letter with your goals in mind.

5. Follow Up and Show Appreciation

Check in with your recommenders about a month before the deadline to make sure they’re on track and see if they need anything further from you. Once they’ve submitted their letters, send a thank-you note expressing your gratitude for their support. This isn’t just polite—it also leaves a positive impression, especially if you need their help again for future recommendations or networking.

A thoughtful note could say: “Thank you so much for taking the time to write my recommendation letter. I truly appreciate your support and the impact your class had on my learning journey.”

6. Understand What Makes an Impactful Letter

Admissions officers are drawn to recommendation letters that offer specific anecdotes and a clear narrative about the applicant’s strengths. Letters that use concrete examples to illustrate qualities like leadership, resilience, and teamwork stand out more than general praises. Admissions readers want to see proof of your character traits and academic abilities in action, as it allows them to visualize you on their campus.

In fact, a recommendation that tells a story can leave a lasting impression. For example, if your math teacher describes how you volunteered to help classmates understand complex concepts after school, they could frame it as a sign of your leadership and collaborative spirit. Admissions officers value such examples because they reveal not just what you achieved, but how you contributed positively to the learning environment.

Real Examples and Insights from Admissions Officers

Admissions officers often share that letters from teachers who witnessed a student overcome challenges are particularly powerful. A letter might describe how a student struggled with chemistry initially but sought extra help, improved, and even assisted others later. This narrative of resilience and growth resonates because it aligns with what colleges seek—students who rise to challenges and grow from them.

In an interview, an admissions officer from Stanford University mentioned the impact of a recommendation letter that detailed a student’s commitment to a community project over several years. The letter highlighted the student’s dedication, organizational skills, and ability to inspire others, painting a picture that grades alone couldn’t show.

In another case, a Yale admissions representative shared that they appreciate letters where teachers comment on a student’s intellectual curiosity or willingness to engage with difficult topics, as this aligns with Yale’s academic culture. For instance, if a teacher shares that you routinely asked thoughtful questions that sparked class discussions, it provides insight into how you contribute academically.

Obtaining a strong letter of recommendation takes time, thoughtful selection of recommenders, and clear communication about your goals. By choosing the right recommenders, preparing them with useful information, and aligning their letters with your application goals, you can create a well-rounded picture of yourself for admissions officers. Remember, the goal of a recommendation letter is to show who you are in a way that grades and test scores can’t—so aim to get letters that reveal your character, commitment, and potential as a college student.

Securing impactful recommendation letters is part of SCHOLARSHIPguy.com’s mission to support you in your journey to college. We offer guidance to help you connect with teachers and mentors who can provide letters that enhance your college applications. With the right support, your application can tell a compelling story that showcases your unique qualities and goals.